I don’t know why this has to be an “either, or” situation. Because it’s both imo. Jewish students are getting hurt because they are Jewish. It doesn’t matter if other Jewish students participate. After all. George Soros is ethnically Jewish, but ye went around and willingly identified Jewish homes so that the Nazis could ship them off to camps. There is the phenomenon of the self-hating Jew. Doesn’t mean that there’s not antisemitism mixed in with their motives
Karlyn, that was an excellent analysis. I know what to look for, mostly, but I had no idea where you were going to take that. Joining forces with another group, even one extremely dissimilar to your own for the purpose of achieving a common secondary goal, is really common throughout history. Thank you!
So let their numbers swell. They will be fighting each other soon enough - just like Occupy Wall Street - which will be a good thing. I'd rather run through this coming cycle sooner rather than later. Yes, they're not primarily about being anti-Semitic - although they are anti-Semitic, no matter what they say - but I say, let them get POed and show up, so we know who they are, and this gets over with sooner.
I don’t know why this has to be an “either, or” situation. Because it’s both imo. Jewish students are getting hurt because they are Jewish. It doesn’t matter if other Jewish students participate. After all. George Soros is ethnically Jewish, but ye went around and willingly identified Jewish homes so that the Nazis could ship them off to camps. There is the phenomenon of the self-hating Jew. Doesn’t mean that there’s not antisemitism mixed in with their motives
Karlyn, that was an excellent analysis. I know what to look for, mostly, but I had no idea where you were going to take that. Joining forces with another group, even one extremely dissimilar to your own for the purpose of achieving a common secondary goal, is really common throughout history. Thank you!
Thanks for breaking it all down.
So let their numbers swell. They will be fighting each other soon enough - just like Occupy Wall Street - which will be a good thing. I'd rather run through this coming cycle sooner rather than later. Yes, they're not primarily about being anti-Semitic - although they are anti-Semitic, no matter what they say - but I say, let them get POed and show up, so we know who they are, and this gets over with sooner.